Global Easy Forex's Forum


  • Discussion about Forex Trading.
     مناقشة حول تجارة الفوركس
    Обсуждение Торговля на Форекс
    Bắt đầu giao dịch ngoại hối ngay bây giờ!
  • Start Trading Forex Now!
     ابدأ تداول الفوركس الآن!
    Начать торговую валюту сейчас!
    Nói về giao dịch ngoại hối
  • Make Forex learning easy!
     جعل تعلم الفوركس سهل!
    Сделайте обучение Forex легким!
    Làm cho việc học ngoại hối thật dễ dàng!
Global Easy Forex is the website that help you know how to start trading forex and related topic financial discussion and news
Start Trading Forex Now! 立即开始外汇交易! ابدأ تداول الفوركس الآن! Начать торговую валюту сейчас! เริ่มเทรดหุ้นฟอร์เร็กซ์ได้เดี๋ยวนี้! Bắt đầu giao dịch ngoại hối ngay bây giờ!
Discussion about Forex Trading. 关于外汇交易的讨论 مناقشة حول تجارة الفوركس Обсуждение Торговля на Форекс พูดคุยเกี่ยวกับการเทรดหุ้นฟอร์เร็กซ์ Nói về giao dịch ngoại hối
Make Forex learning easy! 让外汇学习变得简单! جعل تعلم الفوركس سهل! Сделайте обучение Forex легким! ทำให้การเรียนรู้หุ้นฟอร์เร็กซ์เป็นเรื่องง่าย! Làm cho việc học ngoại hối thật dễ dàng!

Author Topic: Why Are There Still No Bitcoin ETFs?  (Read 103 times)


  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • Posts: 54
    • View Profile
on: September 15, 2018, 01:26:42 PM
2018 has been a lousy year for cryptocurrencies, as bitcoin prices have fallen back below the key $10,000 level that won it so much fanfare coming into the year. That hasn't stopped crypto investors from clamoring for more and better ways to invest in bitcoin and other tokens, and many have wanted to see bitcoin ETFs make it easier for investors to take positions in the cryptocurrency.

For a long time, major players in the bitcoin and financial industries have tried to bring a bitcoin ETF to market. Yet over the past couple of months, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission has denied applications for bitcoin ETFs to start trading on major exchanges. For those who really want an exchange-traded fund vehicle for investing in cryptocurrencies, the explanations from the SEC have been far from satisfying, even as they leave at least a little hope for a future change in the regulatory agency's position.

Why the SEC keeps denying bitcoin ETFs

On Aug. 22, the SEC issued an order disapproving a proposed rule change that would have allowed shares of two bitcoin ETFs to trade on the New York Stock Exchange's NYSE Arca exchange. The exchange, in conjunction with ETF provider ProShares, had filed the rule change proposal in December 2017, seeking to allow the ProShares Bitcoin ETF and the ProShares Short Bitcoin ETF to be listed on NYSE Arca.

It took several months just for the SEC to begin its typical process for evaluating rule changes. After a required comment period, the agency gave itself one more two-month extension, which led to the final decision in August.

In its order, the SEC tried to make it clear that the agency hadn't looked at the validity of bitcoin itself. In the words of the commission, the "disapproval does not rest on an evaluation of whether bitcoin, or blockchain technology more generally, has utility or value as an innovation or investment."

Instead, the SEC's concern remained the threat of fraud or manipulation of the bitcoin market. In particular, the agency said that NYSE Arca hadn't offered enough evidence that the bitcoin futures markets were big enough to fulfill an adequate oversight function to avoid the potential for fraudulent or manipulative acts from wrongdoers.

The SEC and the Winklevosses

The Securities and Exchange Commission referred back to its decision the previous month, in which it prevented the Winklevoss Bitcoin Trust from being listed. Essentially, what the SEC said it wanted to see was that some other bitcoin-related market had enough regulation that those watching trading behavior among bitcoin ETFs would necessarily see warning signs in that other bitcoin market before any fraud or manipulation could occur.

In the case of the Winklevoss ETF, the SEC based its rejection on its assessment of the market for actual bitcoin. Because the Winklevoss ETF was to be set up as a grantor trust in a manner similar to what several other ETFs that hold commodities directly use, the SEC pointed to the uncertainties in the existing market infrastructure for bitcoin itself.

Yet the SEC didn't hesitate to use a similar standard in evaluating the bitcoin futures markets, which the ProShares bitcoin ETFs were designed to track. Several comments addressed the vulnerability of markets for bitcoin and bitcoin futures to manipulation, with one citing so-called pump-and-dump schemes among various players in the cryptocurrency arena. Those comments didn't necessarily provide the sole basis for the SEC's decision, but they did seem to support it.

A glimmer of hope?

Just about the only positive from the SEC in the orders themselves was its repeated statement that NYSE Arca hadn't established that bitcoin futures markets were big enough to give the agency the assurances it wanted. That suggests that if bitcoin futures become more popular in the future, then the SEC might be willing to reconsider its decision upon submission of updated trading figures.

Yet some have taken solace in the fact that after the initial order, the SEC issued a stay of its rejection pending further review. The SEC's commissioners will personally review the findings of staff members to ensure that the rulings were proper, and cryptocurrency advocates think the review could lead to a reversal of the adverse decision.

For now, though, regulators seem to be categorically opposed to allowing bitcoin ETFs to start trading on U.S. exchanges. More ETF providers are likely to try, but until something changes with the cryptocurrency markets as a whole, investors shouldn't expect to buy and sell shares of a bitcoin ETF anytime soon.


Bitcoin is overhyped: 10 better buys for you now
When investing geniuses David and Tom Gardner have a stock tip, it can pay to listen. After all, the newsletter they have run for over a decade, Motley Fool Stock Advisor, has tripled the market.*

David and Tom just revealed what they believe are the ten best stocks for investors to buy right now... and investing directly in Bitcoin was noticeably absent from their recommendations! That's right -- they think these 10 stocks are better buys.



Related Topics

  Subject / Started by Replies Last post
0 Replies
Last post September 05, 2018, 08:32:20 PM
by Marylin095
0 Replies
Last post September 11, 2018, 04:45:31 PM
by Baronnoos
1 Replies
Last post September 20, 2018, 03:41:45 AM
by Dargga
0 Replies
Last post September 19, 2018, 11:54:16 AM
by KenSimonet
0 Replies
Last post October 03, 2018, 01:05:36 PM
by DorothySt

Disclaimer By viewing any material or using the information within this site, you agree that it is general educational material whether it is about learning forex online or not and you will not hold anybody responsible for loss or damages resulting from the content provided here. Investing in financial product is subject to market risk. Financial products, such as stock trading and forex, are very speculative and any investment in them should done carefully, desirably with a good personal risk management. Forex trading, Stock Trading and commodity specultion have big potential rewards but also big potential risk.

Prices movement in the past and past performance of certain traders are by no means an assurance of future performance or any forex market or stock market movement. This website is for informative and discussion purpose in this website only. No one here can makes no warranties or guarantees in respect of the content, whether it is about forex trading or not. Discussion content reflects the views of individual people only. The website bears no responsibility for the accuracy of forum member’s comments whether about learning forex online or not and will bear no responsibility or legal liability for discussion postings.

Investment tutorial, opinions and comments presented on this website do not represent the opinions on who should buy, sell or hold particular investments,forex currency pairs, or any products or forex courses. All investors should conduct their own independent research before making any decision.

The publications herein do not take into account the investment objectives, financial situation or particular needs of any particular person. You should obtain individual financial and forex trading advice based on your own particular circumstances before making an investment decision on the basis of information about forex and non-forex matter on this website.

As a user, you should agree, through acceptance of these terms and conditions, that you should not use this forum to post any content which is abusive, vulgar, hateful, and harassing to any forex traders and non-traders.